Poll: Who Do You Like?

With the winter meeting set to begin next week, Dodgers GM Ned Colletti has made it very clear that starting pitching is his top priority. But quite frankly, the free agent market for starters is very bleak. There are several top-of-the-rotation guys out there who are not free agents, but they would cost the Dodgers a great deal in top prospects (which they have few of) and/or a lot of money (which they seem to have a lot of).

Tampa Bay Rays right-hander James Shields is not a free agent but he may be a trade candidate. The Southern California native will undoubtedly command a great deal in prospects and/or money. (Photo credit – J. Meric)

Here are the names being tossed around as being on Ned Colletti’s radar:

  • Zack Greinke (free agent) – In a year when top-of-the-rotation free agents are at a premium, Greinke is at the very top of the list. And though he may be the best pitcher available, he is not the best pitcher in game – not by any stretch. Unfortunately (for everyone except Zack Greinke, that is), he may very well become the highest paid pitcher in MLB history simply because of the weak free agent market. It is rumored that the 29-year-old Greinke wants a six year deal at $25 per year ($150 million). This would top Matt Cain’s 6-year/$127.5 million deal and even C.C. Sabathia’s record 7-year/$161 million deal (which averages out to $23 million per year). We’re talking Zack Greinke here folks, not Roy Halladay or Justin Verlander.
  • Anibal Sánchez (free agent) – The soon-to-be 29-year-old right-hander has pitched in the big leagues for seven seasons and has a 48-51 record and a career ERA of 3.75, which ain’t bad. His career WHIP is 1.346 which ain’t all that good. He has a career K/9 of 7.6 and a BB/9 of 3.3. Is this the kind of guy that you want to give a 6-year/$90 million contract to (which is what he is seeking)?
  • Kyle Lohse (free agent) – Although Lohse is coming off the best season of his 12-year MLB career, he is 34 years old. And while this might not be a big concern for the next couple of years, it will become a huge concern towards the tail end of the 5 or 6 year deal that he will undoubtedly be seeking. Unfortunately, any team seeking the services of Lohse will also be forced to give up a first round draft pick.
  • Ryan Dempster (free agent) – There’s old and then there’s Ryan Dempster old. Dempster will be 36 in May and although he may be one of the best Cubs pitchers in the past several years, he is anything but the best MLB pitcher in the past several years. Dempster’s 15-year career ERA is 4.33 and his WHIP a staggering 1.430. Dempster is quite a character and a hoot in the clubhouse, but in all honesty, who gives a hoot? Signing Dempster to anything beyond a two-year deal would be a disaster and any team doing so will get exactly what they deserve.
  • James Shields (non-free agent) – Shields is unquestionably one of the best pitchers in the game right now, but he will not be a free agent until 2014. This means that any team wanting his services will undoubtedly have to give the Tampa Bay Rays a boatload of top prospects and probably a ton of money as well. While the cash thing certainly isn’t a problem for the Dodgers, the prospect thing definitely is. Quite frankly, to get the soon-to-be 31-year-old Shields, the Dodgers would probably have to give up both Zach Lee and Chris Reed, not to mention top outfield prospect Joc Pederson – and even that might not do it. That said, Shields is a Southern California native (Newhall, CA) and would undoubtedly love to play for his hometown Dodgers.
  • Ryu Hyun-Jin (non-free agent) – Although the Dodgers won the ($25.7 million) bidding rights to negotiate with the soon-to-be 26-year old Korean superstar, they can walk away from the Boras client without spending a dime on him if they choose. The Dodgers have until December 10 to sign the left-hander and if they do not, he must remain with his current Korean team and will not be available until next year when the bidding process will repeat itself. That said, Jin has made it very clear that he wants to pitch in the MLB and undoubtedly does not want to wait another year to do so. This certainly bodes well for the Dodgers; however you know darn well that Boras certainly isn’t going to give the Dodgers any kind of a deal on his client. I suspect that with the bidding fees, Jin could cost the Dodgers upwards of $50 million for a 5-year deal. My thought is – why not, since the Dodgers seem to have the money.
  • Zach Lee (Dodgers Minor Leaguer) – Zach Lee was the Dodgers first round draft pick in 2010. The 21-year-old right-hander is still the Dodgers top pitching prospect and could very well make it into the Dodgers rotation in 2013, however he will most likely not be on the Opening Day roster. Although Lee has zero MLB experience, he did okay at Single-A Rancho Cucamonga and Double-A Chattanooga this past season going 6-6 with a 4.39 ERA. And though his WHIP was 1.331, he had a very impressive K/9 of 7.6 and a BB/9 of 2.5. I sincerely believe that Zach will be in the starting rotation in 2013 – I’m just not sure that it will be with the Dodgers – if they go after James Shields, that is.
  • Chris Reed (Dodgers Minor Leaguer) – Like Zach Lee, Chris Reed will probably be MLB-ready at some point during the 2013 season, but here again, it may not be with the Dodgers if they go after Shields. The 22-year-old Reed was the Dodgers first round draft pick in 2011 (do you see a pattern here?). Like Lee, Reed spent the 2012 season at Single-A Rancho Cucamonga and Double-A Chattanooga where he posted an ugly combined record of 1-8. Although the left-hander’s ERA was 3.97, his K/9 was 8.8 and his BB/9 was 4.4. Reed also played in the 2012 Arizona Fall League, however he did not fair well there either. If the Dodgers have a choice of keeping Zach Lee or Chris Reed in a trade for Shields, I would hope that they would keep Lee – but let’s be real here, if you’re the Tampa Bay Rays, who would you take?

Although he won’t come cheap, Korean superstar lefty Ryu Hyun-Jin won’t cost the Dodgers any prospects or future draft picks. (Photo credit – Mark J. Terrill)

So, who do you like and why?

Which Starting Pitchers Should the Dodgers Go After? (SELECT TWO)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...


Both comments and pings are currently closed.

14 Responses to “Poll: Who Do You Like?”

  1. Bluenose Dodger says:

    I expect the Dodgers will go the free agent route since money is not an issue and a shortage of young pitchers in the minor league system now is an issue. I expect Greinke is definitely in the cross hairs and I have no doubt that Ryn Hyun-Jin will be signed. From what I can read, there are mixed reviews on him.

    Much of the present pitching conundrum is the result of Chad Billingsly’s health so the team will be after two starters to go along with Clayton and Josh Beckett. That is, upgrades over Harang, Lilly and Capuano. Capuano, at least, would have some trade value.

    I would be hesitant to trade for Shields who is a free agent after the 2013 season. Trading the farm for him is definitely risky. eg. Ethan Martin and Josh Lindblom for Shane Victorino. I hate when that happens.
    I really want Lee, especially, to still be with the Dodgers at the end of 2013. Onelki Garcia is also of interest to see how he progresses in 2013.

    If a trade was in the cards, my preference would be Jeremy Hellickson, 26 in April, whose first three years match Shields’ first three years. He would not cost nearly as much in prospects as Shields.

    Dempster would be OK for a year, but not the longer term upgrade needed, 36 in May. Lohse is 34 so not a three year guy in my opinion. Sanchez would be expensive but apparently money is not an issue. If it isn’t then Greinke gives the Dodgers a better chance of winning than Sanchez over the next few years.

    From the list above, I vote to keep Lee and Reed and sign Greinke and Ryu Hyun-Jin.

  2. funkyjam says:

    Hello! Looks like I took Zack Greinke and Ryu Hyun-Jin 🙂

    1. Greinke – He is the best FA pitcher out there. Immediate upgrade over everybody in the rotation not named Clayton Kershaw. Perfect compliment to CK. Dodgers have money, but for some reason I feel like he wont be the highest paid pitcher ever. Will be a lot I’m sure, but if I’m wrong, heh whatevs.

    2. Hyun-Jin – Arguably the best pitcher in the KBO over the past decade. Multiple Strikeout and ERA titles(KBO). Team needs more international talent. An influx of Korean culture I predict will hit Amarican shores real soon and Ryu fits that description and being Korean would hopefully attract more to Dodger stadium. Even though he has that question mark due to the league that he played in, the numbers hes accumulated, there’s something there. And if he gets lit up, Dodgers offense should be there to help him. Very intriguing and I hope the Dodgers sign him.

  3. Bluenose Dodger says:

    First vote for Shields seemed to be a single vote. When I voted for Greinke and and Hyun-Jin there were then two for each of them and one for Shields.

  4. Evan Bladh says:

    I voted for Greinke and Ryu. Truth is I’m not real enthusiastic about any of them, but there’s no Hamels or Sabathia available. A lousy year for the team to suddenly get rich.

  5. ebbetsfld says:

    I’m holding off ’til I see how OBF votes!


    I have a nagging feeling Grienke will end up with Texas. I certainly hope I’m wrong (reverse thinking here folks 🙂
    I pick Grienke.


    And the other I say go with Lee.

  8. MFGRREP says:

    I chose Greinke and RYU because we already have Lee and Reed if we need them. Point is buy the player don’t trade for the player, which would be Greinke and RYU

  9. echavez2 says:

    Go big or go Home! Gotta go with the best on the market Greinke! Not sold on Ryu yet. would be nice to see shields.

  10. Cranbrook Curt says:

    I chose Shields and Greinke. I just think that those two are the best guys for the dodgers. And not too mention that James Shiels is te type of guy that keeps the club house loose and fun.

Powered by WordPress