Best MLB Draft Ever

For the better part of five decades, the Dodgers 1968 draft class was considered to be the best in the history of the MLB First-Year Player Draft. At the time, the draft was conducted in four different phases — two in January and two in June. The January phases were for high school kids who had graduated, community college players, or players who had reached the age of 21.

The regular January phase was for players who hadn’t been drafted before, the secondary phase for those who had previously been drafted. The regular June phase was for all high school and college players who hadn’t been drafted previously; the secondary phase was for all previously drafted players.

The Dodgers signed a total of 11 future big leaguers from that draft class who combined for more than 235 Wins Above Replacement (WAR) and five others who had at least ‘a-cup-of-coffee’ in the Major Leagues. Six of the players signed by the Dodgers would go on to become MLB All-Stars for a total of 23 Mid-Summer Classic appearances:

The MLB Draft Class of 1968 is arguable the best ever by the Dodgers and perhaps in all of baseball. It produced three-quarters of “The Infield” of Ron Cey, Bill Russell (drafted by the Dodgers in 1966), Davey Lopes, and Steve Garvey, seen here during an ‘Old-Timers Day’ event Dodger Stadium.
(Photo credit – Ron Cervenka)

Other members of the 1968 Dodgers draft class included: outfielder Joe Ferguson (University of Pacific, Stockton, California); Bobby Valentine (Rippowam High School, Stamford, Connecticut); and pitcher Geoff Zahn (University of Michigan). What General Manager Al Campanis accomplished in that draft put the team in position to compete for World Championships for more than a decade.

No other Major League team has come close to the overall quality of that Dodgers draft. But based on their minor league careers to date, there is a recent draft class that has a legitimate shot to one-day replace that 1968 class as the best ever; the Dodgers 2016 draft, which included: middle infielder Gavin Lux, catcher Will Smith, pitcher Jordan Sheffield, pitcher Mitchell White, pitcher Dustin May, outfielder DJ Peters, middle infielder Errol Robinson, outfielder Luke Raley, pitcher Tony Gonsolin, outfielder Cody Thomas, catcher Steve Berman, and middle infielder Zach McKinstry.

Twenty-five-year-old Dodgers outfield prospect Cody Thomas absolutely stole the show this past Spring before the coronavirus forced the shutdown of Major League Baseball … and the world.
(Video capture courtesy of SportsNet LA)

There is no way to know which of these players will ever make it to The Show, let alone be regulars or All-Stars. Dodgers fans can only watch and enjoy their respective development, hoping that one day they will be as good – or better – than Messrs Buckner, Lopes, Cey, and Garvey, and will one day form the nucleus of future World Championships.

  *  *  *  *  *  * 

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

4 Responses to “Best MLB Draft Ever”

  1. Ron Cervenka says:

    As a teenager (and twenty-ager), I used to love going to Dodger Stadium to watch “The Infield” play (along with watching Dr. Mike Marshall pitch). But with what free agency has become, I do not think we will ever again see a group of players – even if drafted in the same year class – remain together like Lopes, Russell Garvey and Cey did, let alone remain on the same team for their entire careers.

    • Jesse Pearce says:

      Excellent point! Free agency and CBT make it next to impossible to have a group of star players together for an extended period.

  2. DOUG CEY says:

    Well, I can sort of speak firsthand to this, being the younger and better-looking brother of the Penguin. Tom Paciorek crushed it in Triple A and was my brother’s roommate in Spokane and Albuquerque, Tommy LaSorda was the manager. Had Billy Buckner not corked his bat, and got traded to the Cubs, he could have possibly helped the Dodgers beat the Yankees more than once in 5 years. I was a teenager in the 70’s and came down to LA every summer (from Tacoma) for a Dodger homestand, and worked out on the field with the subs. Tommy would once in awhile throw me batting practice, but the best day when was Hall of Famer Don Newcombe came to the park, and I got to hit off him for 20 minutes…yes, a phenomenal draft indeed. The battles with the Reds of the 70’s, wow! Rose, Morgan, Bench, Griffey, Foster, Geronimo, Concepcion. Great times for baseball.

    • Ron Cervenka says:

      GREAT reply, Doug! Thank you for dropping in on us. I was a HUGE fan of your brother ‘back in the day.’

      Please don’t be a stranger around these parts. You are ALWAYS welcome here and are now officially a TBLA family member.

      Thanks again!

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress